Try Our New BETA Version
(navigation image)
Home Animation & Cartoons | Arts & Music | Community Video | Computers & Technology | Cultural & Academic Films | Ephemeral Films | Movies | News & Public Affairs | Prelinger Archives | Spirituality & Religion | Sports Videos | Television | Videogame Videos | Vlogs | Youth Media
Search: Advanced Search
Anonymous User (login or join us)

View movie

item imageitem imageitem imageitem image

View thumbnails

Play / Download (help[help])

(396.8 M)Ogg Video
(412.3 M)512Kb MPEG4
(1.1 G)MPEG4

All Files: HTTPS Torrent (2/0)
[Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States]



Joly MacFieNYC Council - .nyc public hearing (2008)

something has gone horribly wrong 8-p
Prefer flash? · Embed · Questions/Feedback?

On October 17 2008 Council Member Gale A. Brewer (D-Manhattan), Chair of the NYC Council's Technology in Government Committee, held a hearing regarding the City's interest for a unique .nyc Top Level Domain (TLD). As we maybe familiar (from his earlier presentation) Tom Lowenhaupt has for some years been spearheading a local community-based effort - 'Connecting .nyc' - to acquire the .nyc TLD on behalf of the city. At the ICANN meeting in Paris in July the road was cleared for a new round of applications starting early in 2009. Other cities such as Paris and Berlin are also actively pursuing TLDs. There was still some uncertainty as to cost, and also to procedure, particularly if there were more than one applicant. While in general new TLDs were to go to the highest bidder, ICANN let it be known that, in the case of municipal applications, preference would be given to applicants approved by the local authorities. Thus Council Member Brewer sponsored Resolution 1495-2008 that urged ICANN to approve such an application, and this hearing was held where the applicants, and the public, could comment. Tom gave his presentation, with comments from Hannah Kopelman his resident advisor, and Michael Palage, his ICANN advisor. Council Member Bill DeBlasio sharply questioned the need for any external body to run the domain - rather then the City itself. Dr. Frans Verhagen made brief comments on the sustainability benefits of a TLD. Then came Paul Garrin of Paul is something of a namespace renegade, attempting in the late 90's to set up a rival to the established domain name system with many TLDs. He sued ICANN's predecessor Network Solutions for access to the root. His proposals for just under 500 new TLDs were also, despite expert arguments, since generally accepted, deemed technically impractical. Nethertheless He won his case on appeal but NetSol were granted immunity as government contractors. Control of the domain system was soon transferred to ICANN. In ICANN's first round of TLD expansion in 2000 he applied for many domains including .nyc, paying a $50K application fee. The application was not successful but, as far as can be ascertained, is still pending. He considers's right to operate a .nyc TLD is well established. His plans are to operate the TLD for the city's benefit and is a supporter of Tom Lowenhaupt's ideas on community management. The next panel brought up representatives of Names@Work. Antony Van Gouvering talked of the company's professional experience starting/managing/selling country code TLDs. The company applied for a .nyc tld in 2000 but withdrew for lack of funding. Antony listed current cities interested in TLDs as London, Paris, Boston, Berlin, Chicago, Hamburg, Munich, Toronto, Tokyo, Barcelona, and Portland. He noted the failures of several previously established TLDs which he ascribed mostly to a lack of marketing. He suggests that rather than a community run TLD that a 'community partner' be the recipient of a portion of the profits from a commercial enterprise, with some second-level domains reserved for community use. He was quite prepared to work with Tom on community aspects. Davidson Goldin stressed the company's ability to address prectical aspects of domain management and all of the city council's concerns. Lastly Jack Eichenbaum of GISMO spoke about geographic integration.

00:00:00 Gale A. Brewer - Introduction
05:15:16 Thomas Lowenhaupt,
21:57:10 Hannah Kopelman,
23:31:31 Michael Palage,
35:29:54 Bill DeBlasio - questions
01:07:01 Frans C. Verhagen, Sustainability Sociologist
01:11:51 Paul Garrin, Name.Space
01:24:37 Antony Van Couvering, Names@Work
01:30:23 Davidson Goldin, Names@Work
01:35:21 Jack Eichenbaum, GISMO

Original post:

This movie is part of the collection: Punkcast

Producer: Joly MacFie
Production Company:
Sponsor: ISOC-NY.ORG
Audio/Visual: sound, color
Language: English
Keywords: isoc-ny; Internet Society; ICANN; NYC;
Contact Information:

Creative Commons license: Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States

Individual Files

Movie Files Animated GIF MPEG4 Ogg Video 512Kb MPEG4 Thumbnail
iPod 357.7 KB 
1.1 GB 
396.8 MB 
412.3 MB 
5.7 KB 
Information FormatSize
punkcast1451_files.xml Metadata [file] 
punkcast1451_meta.xml Metadata 5.8 KB 
punkcast1451_reviews.xml Metadata 176.0 B 
Other Files Archive BitTorrent
punkcast1451_archive.torrent 40.3 KB 

Be the first to write a review
Downloaded 711 times

Terms of Use (31 Dec 2014)